Research article
The Constitutive and Conventional Nature of Legal Interpretation Directives
Konstytutywny i konwencjonalny charakter dyrektyw wykładni prawa
Archiwum Filozofii Prawa i Filozofii Społecznej, nr 2(43)/2025, s. 80-96
English
Abstract
The article’s purpose is to demonstrate that the directives of legal interpretation are constitutive and conventional. The directives of legal interpretation are constitutive because they confer the status of legal interpretive practice on social practice. The directives of legal interpretation are conventional because they are arbitrary in the sense given to them by A. Marmor. The directives of legal interpretation constitute not only the legal interpretive practice, but also the values of this practice. Among these values, I include innovative thinking, reasoning by analogy, intellectual challenges. If constitutive conventions are responsive, i.e., if they respond to various human needs and values, then at the core of legal interpretive practice there are values that are momentous for those who participate in these practices. Two types of values are distinguished: values in a strong sense and in a weak sense. Values in the strong sense are values whose realization is acontextual, i.e., independent of any context of a given legal interpretive practice. I include certainty and uniformity of understanding of legal texts in this category of values. On the other hand, values in the weak sense are contextual values, i.e., ones that depend on the goals that legal interpretive practice is supposed to fulfil. Examples of contextual values are adaptability and stability of law. I considered that there is a special relationship between values in both the strong and weak senses and the directives of legal interpretation. Based on mutual expectations, members of a given community assume that a particular directive of legal interpretation best realizes an important value of legal interpretation. The correctness of the above relationship largely depends on previous legal interpretive practice.
Keywords
- legal interpretation directives
- constitutive rule
- conventional rule
- values in legal interpretive practice
References
18 reference entries
References
-
Dyrda A., Konwencja u podstaw prawa. Kontrowersje pozytywizmu prawniczego, Wolters Kluwer, Warszawa 2013.
-
Dyrda A., Gizbert-Studnicki T., Granice sporów interpretacyjnych w prawoznawstwie, „Archiwum Filozofii Prawa i Filozofii Społecznej” 2020, nr 2, s. 19–34.
-
Gizbert-Studnicki T., The Normativity of Rules of Interpretation, w: Problems of Normativity, Rules and Rule-Following, eds. M. Araszkiewicz, P. Banaś, T. Gizbert-Studnicki, K. Płeszka, Springer, Cham 2015, s. 243–254.
-
Korycka-Zirk M., Milczący prolog konstytucji, „Państwo i Prawo” 2023, z. 1, s. 143–153.
-
Lagerspetz E., Opposite mirrors. An essay in the conventionalist theory of institutions, Springer, Dor-drecht – Boston – London 1995.
-
Lewis D., Convention. A Philosophical Study, Blackwell, Oxford 1969.
-
Marmor A., Social Conventions, Princeton University Press, Princeton – Oxford 2009.
-
Pietrzykowski T., John R. Searle i ontologia prawa, „Studia Prawnicze” 2009, nr 1–2, s. 7–41.
-
Raban O., The Silent Prologue. How Judicial Philosophies Shape Our Constitutional Rights, George Manson University Press, Fairfax 2020.
-
Searle J., Speech Acts, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 1969.
-
Searle J., The Construction of Social Reality, Simon and Shuster Inc., London – New York 1995.
-
Smolak M., Wykładnia celowościowa z perspektywy pragmatycznej, Wolters Kluwer, Warszawa 2012.
-
Wróblewski J., Prawo. Metodologia. Filozofia. Teoria prawa, PWN, Warszawa 1991.
-
Wróblewski J., Wartości a decyzja sądowa, Ossolineum, Wrocław – Warszawa – Kraków 1973.
-
Wróblewski J., Zagadnienie jednolitości i pewności rozumienia tekstów prawnych, „Państwo i Pra-wo” 1966, z. 3, s. 539–558.
-
Zieliński M., Wykładnia prawa. Zasady – reguły – wskazówki, Wolters Kluwer, Warszawa 2017.
-
Zieliński M., Bogucki O., Hoduń A., Czepita S., Kanarek B., Municzewski A., Zintegrowanie polskich koncepcji wykładni prawa, „Ruch Prawniczy, Ekonomiczny i Socjologiczny” 2004, z. 4, s. 26–27.
-
Zirk-Sadowski M., Prawo w kulturze. Eseje wybrane z teorii i filozofii prawa, Wolters Kluwer, War -szawa 2023.
Publication information
Issue data
Issue nr 2(43)/2025
- Pages
- 80-96
- Published
How to cite
Bibliographic description and verified export formats.
Format AFPiFS
M. Smolak, The Constitutive and Conventional Nature of Legal Interpretation Directives, „Archiwum Filozofii Prawa i Filozofii Społecznej” nr 2(43)/2025, s. 80–96, DOI: 10.36280/afpifs.2025.2.80
ACM
[1] Marek Smolak. 2025. The Constitutive and Conventional Nature of Legal Interpretation Directives. AFPiFS 2(43) (2025), 80–96. https://doi.org/10.36280/afpifs.2025.2.80
ACS
(1) Smolak, M. The Constitutive and Conventional Nature of Legal Interpretation Directives. AFPiFS 2025, No. 2(43), 80–96. https://doi.org/10.36280/afpifs.2025.2.80.
APA
Smolak, M. (2025). The Constitutive and Conventional Nature of Legal Interpretation Directives. Archiwum Filozofii Prawa i Filozofii Społecznej, 2(43), 80–96. https://doi.org/10.36280/afpifs.2025.2.80
ABNT
SMOLAK, Marek. The Constitutive and Conventional Nature of Legal Interpretation Directives. Archiwum Filozofii Prawa i Filozofii Społecznej, n. 2(43), p. 80–96, 2025.
Chicago
Smolak, Marek. “The Constitutive and Conventional Nature of Legal Interpretation Directives.” Archiwum Filozofii Prawa i Filozofii Społecznej, no. 2(43) (2025): 80–96. https://doi.org/10.36280/afpifs.2025.2.80.
Harvard
Smolak, M. (2025) “The Constitutive and Conventional Nature of Legal Interpretation Directives,” Archiwum Filozofii Prawa i Filozofii Społecznej, 2(43), pp. 80–96. Available at: https://doi.org/10.36280/afpifs.2025.2.80.
IEEE
[1] M. Smolak, “The Constitutive and Conventional Nature of Legal Interpretation Directives,” AFPiFS, no. 2(43), pp. 80–96, 2025, doi: 10.36280/afpifs.2025.2.80.
MLA
Smolak, Marek. “The Constitutive and Conventional Nature of Legal Interpretation Directives.” Archiwum Filozofii Prawa i Filozofii Społecznej, no. 2(43), 2025, pp. 80–96, https://doi.org/10.36280/afpifs.2025.2.80.
Turabian
Smolak, Marek. “The Constitutive and Conventional Nature of Legal Interpretation Directives.” Archiwum Filozofii Prawa i Filozofii Społecznej, no. 2(43) (2025): 80–96. https://doi.org/10.36280/afpifs.2025.2.80.
Vancouver
1. Smolak M. The Constitutive and Conventional Nature of Legal Interpretation Directives. AFPiFS. 2025;2(43):80–96. doi:10.36280/afpifs.2025.2.80
OSCOLA
Marek Smolak, ‘The Constitutive and Conventional Nature of Legal Interpretation Directives’ (2025) 2(43) AFPiFS 80 <https://doi.org/10.36280/afpifs.2025.2.80>.